Thursday, June 6, 2019
The Science Behind Love Essay Example for Free
The Science Behind Love EssayWhat is this thing called savour? There atomic number 18 so many definitions that mass thunder mug come up with for crawl in. Some are easy to understand trance differents do non make that often sense. Many mass pretend that experience is slightlything that happens in a split of a second. Actually what people dont know almost enjoy is that it does not happen in a split of a second. Psychologists and scientists devour reassure that in order for someone to fall in cacoethes, it would take at least 90 seconds to 4 proceedings (Fisher, 2004). Many studies have been do to prove that the brilliance of the unmarried that is in love goes through a weird domino effect. It produces certain chemicals that make the unmarried act strange when the somebody is in love. It has overly been said that in a way, erudition screwing help people that are in relationships (The maturation of romance, 2007).So the main questions would be that what are the chemicals that make a person in love and what are the tips that science can offer to benefit the relationships of people who are in love? Many people have this one question in their psyche what is love? What is the full definition of it? There is no one definite definition for it but one can conclude that love is something magical and it is something that everyone experiences in their life at one point. So what does love do to a person? How does it make them feel physically, emotionally, and handstally? When a person is in love, physically it does not really do that much. It does not heighten how to person looks or anything. What love does to a person is more mental and emotional changes.Mentally what love does to a person is that it makes them crazy in other words, it makes them do some weird things (Middleton Anderson, 2006). Emotionally what love does to a person is that it makes them love someone else who is their everything in their life. At fourth dimensions it i s weird how a person who is so much in love acts they would say stupid things and do stupid things too (Thorton, Carmody, 2010). Many studies have been done to show that love does not involve just the heart. It also involves the brain.Read morePersuasive Essay Example About LoveActually the brain does play a spacious part in the whole sequence of love. In other words, it goes through some weird domino effect that no one had ever conception about. Researchers have set up out that there are these certain chemicals, or more like hormones, that are produced in the body which are sent to the brain (Murphy,m2001). These certain chemicals would be oxytocin, serotonin, and dopamine. The parts of the brain that these chemicals play on the most would be the hippocampus and the thalamus (Murphy, 2001).There are many differences that can be said between men and women when they are in love. According to researchers, they say that women are more willing to make a change in the relationship whi le at times, men are just there. Men do some things to make a relationship work but not as much as the women would do it. Now researchers are wondering is it because of the chemicals that are in the brain that is making the women act much differently than the men.Researchers have also found out the in women, there is a higher amount of serotonin and dopamine but in men, there is a higher level of oxytocin (Young, 2009). It is due to the cause that since women produce estrogen where men produce testerone so it is due to these factors that men and women have different levels of these three chemicals that help play the subroutine of love (Young,2009).They also those animals also have many differences among the humans. It is true that animals do experience love just the way that humans do and to some extent, they also have the same chemicals in their brains as well but not as much as the humans do (Rooks,2009).So what kind of love has to happen in order for the brain to be the major factor in the love process? Researchers have concluded that it can be roughly any type of love. It can be a crush, deep love, intense love or any type of love that exist in this man today. Studies have sh hold that it takes about 90 seconds to 4 minutes to actually like someone or even possibly fall in love with them (Fisher 2004). It is beauteous interesting that you can fall in love with someone within seconds and minutes but what does that brain have to do it? Lets seek some of the studies that certain scientists have done.One of the famous studies that have been was by Helen Fisher who is a professor at Rutgers University in New Jersey. Fisher had a hypothesis where the three chemicals dopamine, norepinephrine and serotonin have a major role in the brain when a person is in love. She decided to manage a train where she would give the volunteers a picture of the person that they love then showing them another picture of someone else. This test would tell us how quickly the b rain reacts with these three chemicals in play. After that, their brains would be scanned under a brain scanner which would show more evidence for this experiment. It would show the kin flow activity that happens when the chemicals play around with the brain.Many volunteers were interested in this case sight yet there were some groups of people that were not allowed to take part in the case. quite a little with some type of metal in their heads, for example lip ring or braces were not allowed to be in the deal. People that were claustrophobic or were left handed were not allowed either. They wanted people that were passionately in love and that could hardly eat, sleep or drink because they are that much in love. Fisher was astonished with the results that she found upon this study.Her exact finding in this study was that the three chemicals that she used in her hypothesis were correct to begin with scientists only when concluded that body movements is what make us react when we are in love but now it is proven to fact that the brain has its own central and network for the actions that are related in love. Her conclusion was that there was a part of the brain that played around the most with the emergences. All three of the chemicals that she used in her hypothesis were also in the brain that played the major part when a person is in love.There was this dopamine fuss lode. What this does is that it elevated the amount of dopamine that goes into the brain when the person was in love. Many people think that love is a very small process that happens in the brain but it is clearly a much more difficult process (Fisher, 2004). Another famous study that was done was by the authors Bianch-Demicheli, Grafton and Ortigue (2006).Bianch-Demicheli, Grafton and Ortigue combined their findings when they conducted experiments where they would tell their study subjects the name of their lovers and with that, they would scan their brains and see how the brain reacts wh en basically their lover is the only thing that is in their mind.Another study was conducted where instead of saying the subjects lovers name they would say a favorite sport, TV show or something along that nature and see the difference it has on the brain. They had about 46 participants that were willing to be part of the study.Two studies were conducted yet it was sepa swand in men and women. The results were that there was a similar reaction time that happened between both experiments yet for the women, there was a little faster reaction time where they could think of their beloved much faster than the men. The time that they would think about their lover to the time that they would think about their favorite past time was the same. It also showed that their responses to the to lovers name was much more quick in the brain then the responses to their favorite pastime.The study that was done by Ortigue and her team explains to us that actually what parts of the brain are active wh en that individual is in love. It also does a control experiment where instead of using the individuals lovers picture, they would use another picture of some type of hobby that they like to do. By showing both the lovers picture and the picture of their favorite hobby, at times, the brain levels were almost the same. sympathetic studies have been done to conclude the same facts and data that Fisher and Ortigue and team have found in their experiments. Robert Epstein teaches a course on relationship science where he makes his students participate in numerous amounts of experiments that would prove in a way what science has to do with relationship and how they can help as well. Robert Epstein is a professor at the University of California where he teaches a course on relationship science.He believes that in order for his students to understand the subject matter better, they should have hands-on exercises and experiments, one of which is Soul Gazing where he would pair each of the st udents with someone else and have them look deeply into each others eyes. From this whole class, 89 percent of them experienced a lot of intimacy feelings between them. Epstein then explains to us how almost half of the US original marriages fail and he believes that the only way to fix the poor relationship performance is to find a practical technology technique (2010) and then teach it to the people.. In a study that was done by James D. Laird and his fellow colleagues in 1989, Epstein says that Mutual Eye Gazing made the subjects in the study have a lot of feelings which rapidly increased. Those feelings made the subjects like and love total strangers. Both Soul Gazing and Mutual Gazing increased intimacy and it made the people feel vulnerable. A lot of the exercises showed some apparent results between males and females. One of the males showed no positive effects when he did the exercise with another guy. To him, it made him feel very uncomfortable.Yet when he did the exercis e with a girl, his intimacy rate went up by 25 percent but the girls rate went up by 144 percent By this, once can conclude that girls have more intimacy feelings then boys. One of the students Olivia did another exercise Secret Swap where it creates vulnerability when people overlap their close secrets with each other. When Olivia did this exercise with her mother, both intimacy and vulnerability rates went up 31 percent. She did the Soul Gazing with a total stranger and her intimacy rate went up 70 percent. Its quite amazing that with a total stranger, your intimacy rates go up.There are some examples of movies and books that can demonstrate these findings that these scientists have found. One good example that can easily relate would the famous story of Romeo and Juliet. With the studies that Robert Epstein has conducted, Romeo and Juliet are closely related. In the story, Romeo and Juliet see each other for the first time and right then and there, they fall in love. In other w ords, this can be stated as love at first sight.This can conclude the studies by Epstein and Fisher when she said that a person can fall in love with someone from 90 seconds to 4 minutes. Romeo and Juliet just see each other for the very first time and instantly they fell in love. People in the modern world still think that love is so unrealistic. Honestly in a way, that is kind of weird because they did not even know each other for even a minute and they fell in love.Another example of these findings would this Indian movie called Kuch Kuch Hota Hai, directed by Karan Johar. This movie is about two friends Rahul and Anjali in college and they are scoop friends throughout their four years of college. Everyone would think that they are in love but they are not really.Rahul would always say that I am waiver to find the perfect girl for me and Anjali would help him out. Until the day another girl Tina came. Right then and there, Rahul started to fall in love with Tina but there was cypher more than flirting between them. Then during their English literature class, they were talking about Shakespeare and his Romeo and Juliet story. The question was asked what is love? This was Rahuls answer Love is friendship (Kuch Kuch Hota Hai, 1998).Anjali was in shocked because her and Rahul were really good friends and she started to think that Rahul did like her. She started to fall in love with Rahul but really, he was in love with Tina and Anjali was devastated with this so she decided to put up college because she could not bear to see the Rahul and Tina in love because she really loves Rahul but he takes her nothing more than a friend. This type of movie can be closely related would be the Ortigues and her team.In conclusion, there is science behind the whole concept of love. It is not only involved with the heart and mind but the parts of the brain are also involved. Now that everyone knows the full definition of love and now everyone would think twice when they fa ll in love with someone. ReferencesBrownless, S. (1997). Cant do without love. U.S. News World Report, 122 (6), 58This term talks about how science nowadays are related to love and how people react. Studies have shown that a certain chemical oxytocin plays a major role in the brain. The author also explains a certain study that was done on rodents and the results from that.Epstein, R. (2010). How science can help you fall in love. Scientific the Statesn Mind 20(7), 26-33This denomination explains to us how in a successful love relationship, science can play major role. The author conducted a lot of studies that would prove to us that science can help with relationships and how it can fix Americas poor relationship status.Helmuth, L. (2000). Love on the brain. Science Now, 3This article explains a specific case study that was done on students from a London. It tells us the specific brain areas that are highly activate when those students were in love.Middleton, L. Anderson, A. (2 006). What is this thing called love? New Scientist 190(2549), 32-34This article helps us understand whether science can help us understand love even more. Scientists are now finding certain chemicals in the brain that helps a person fall in love. It also explains to us how a person falls in love using that certain chemical.Murphy, L. (2001). Its all in your mind. Psychology Today, 34(5), 26This article tells us specifically which areas in the brain are deeply effected when a person is in love. The author conducts a special case study and tell us future findings in how we should measure love.Ortigue, S., Grafton, T.S., Demicheli-Bianchi, F. (2006). The power of love on the human brain. Social Neuroscience, 1 (20), 90-103.This article tells us about the new-fangled discovery of the brain and how it is related and how it reacts when a person is in love. It talks about two experiments that has be done by these authors and their findings from each of the experiments.Rooks, J.P. (2009). The science of love. Skeptic, 15(1), 73-74This article talks about how animals brain are somewhat related to the humans brain. It also tells us what we can conclude from this finding.The maturation of romance. (2007) Harvard Mental Health Letter, 23(9), 6-7This article discusses the study that is done on romantic love. It uses a another study as a reference from H. E. Fischer and come to the fact that love is related to one of the brain systems and with that, it becomes much stronger.Thorthon, E.K. Carmody, P. D. (2010). Depression, love, happiness and the quantitative electroencephalography in a single case study. Biofeedback, 38 (1), 13-18. The authors of this article talk about how closely related emotions and how the brain functions are. They explain to use how different emotions (sad, happy, being in love) react in the brain by doing a case study and explaining to us the results and the conclusions founded by the authors.Young, LJ. (2009). Being human love neuroscience revea ls all. Nature, 457(7226), 148This article talks about how the brain reacts differently in both men and women. The author describes how men are different compared to how women are different and also how their brain scans are different too.
Wednesday, June 5, 2019
The Importance Of Sustainable Infrastructure Design Environmental Sciences Essay
The Importance Of sustainable Infrastructure Design Environmental Sciences EssayInfrastructure is the key to creating a healthy, happy and thriving economical climate in communities around the world. It is important to our future success and plays a critical role in creating and enhancing sustainability establish on ESEM principles. By tradition, the leading concern among engineers has been the safety and dependability of major al-Qaeda entities. Until recently, sustainability has not been included in most al-Qaeda organisms on any level. However, the engineering organization, along with the community as a whole, is recognizing the richness of sustainable stem institution. Yet combining these ideas into the engineering bearing procedure as a primary goal remains uncertain to many engineers. This explore paper seeks to provide a program for upcoming sustainable engineering of civil stem intention.IntroductionThe definition behind this search paper is the sustainable spi rit of pertly radical, re-design, rehabilitation, re-use or optimization of current infrastructure, which is consistent with the ESEM principles of sustainability. sustainable infrastructure design is a great modern solution that bequeath greatly drop the emotional state cycle cost of an infrastructure and also less negative effect on the environment. The main goal of this look into paper is to delimitate sustainable infrastructure, the need for infrastructure sustainability design, the scope of sustainable design, how to promote and implement it and the impact of it in society.US infrastructure demographicLets pull up the infrastructure demographic in the US $2.2 trillion is the total investment totality needed in next five years to begin the infrastructure up to top,according to the ASCE recent report. $1.57 is the amountfrom each tax payer spent on infrastructure. There is four one million million miles ofroadsin the U.S and 90,000 miles found to be in dangerous state.1 50, 000 miles of roads are on the agenda to be repaired under the freshlyly $50 billion infrastructure stimulus. $350 to $750 is the average dollar sign amount each driver in the US pays in annual vehicle aid costsrelated to poor road state. 600,000is the number ofbridgesin the U.S and 71,000of those bridges are found to be in alarming state. 140,000 miles ofrailway trackin the national freight rail network. $8 billion is the dollar amount the U.S.plans to spendon aiming high speed rail in the next two years.The need for sustainable infrastructure designAs you may notice from this infrastructure demographic was conducted by the Ameri throw out Society of Civil Engineers recently. The US spends a couple of trillions of dollars every year in mental synthesis, maintaining, repairing and research in infrastructure. Infrastructure development is a vital part of society and economy which develop the need to develop a sustainable infrastructure design to reduce the life cycle cost of the structure and reduce the negative impact on the environment. Let analyze the definition of sustainable infrastructure which is an infrastructure that enable a society evolution towards the goal of sustainable living. More Consideration should be brought to technical and government policies that solelyow the engineers to target at sustainable infrastructure design and ingenuities that promote sustainable living in modern society. Rationally, a sustainable design clues to the expansion of sustainable societies. The main purpose is to reduce a persons ecological footprint according to the ESEM principles and sustainable expansion. Commonly speaking, sustainable infrastructure includes public transport, production and distribution of power, buildings for living, office spaces and public utilities, such as airports, stations, roads and marine ports, etcIn a metropolitan environment, buildings ingest about 40% of power and thus, they are a main supplier to carbon emissions.Sustainab le Infrastructure scopeDesign and manufacture of sustainable buildings can address climate change matters to a large degree. It is projected that each 1 million sq. ft. of constructed sustainable building area will decrease 12 to 17 thousand tons of CO2 each year. Societies ought to improve their sustainable infrastructure design in order to simplify economic development and its capability to develop on a sustainable source depends on how positively it pacts with environmental challenges acclivitous from the development of building a sustainable infrastructure. It is very significant for the US to dynamically chase sharp emission reduction goals. There are massive resources at our disposal The US can establish the possibility and attraction of low-carbon development to other societies by establishing a sustainable infrastructure design based upon the ESEM principles.Sustainable infrastructure design is critical to a sustainable US. Expansion of the population and economic growth p ressure the countrys limited resources of land, water, food, and power. To conserve and develop fellowship of life there is a need to develop sustainable infrastructure design an improvement that meets human necessities for infrastructures firearm saving and guarding environmental quality and the economic and social resources critical for future growth. Sustainable infrastructure design is not luxurious like some might think. There are many examples that can be cited where sustainable infrastructure design has helped significantly reduce life cycle cost, help the environment and promote economic growth. Todays Infrastructure consist of create facilities and shelter and support most human activities infrastructures of all types, power interpret, water supply and waste treatment and management. Infrastructure is crucial socially and economically.In the U.S building and renovating the current infrastructure totals to about 1/8 of the GDP. To create a sustainable infrastructure des ign we need applicable practices, training, and study of infrastructure planning, design, wrench, operation, maintenance and rejuvenation or elimination. The practice, training and study for Sustainable Infrastructure design is one of the creativity of the U.S. infrastructure society. Contribution is exposed to all establishments that harvest, use, study or teach for practices for infrastructure in general. Sustainable infrastructure design outlook supports a great and sustainable quality of life for all individuals in a changing world. Sustainable infrastructure design goal is to progress and integrate ideas and information of sustainability into the principles and practices used without the life cycle of any infrastructure structures.ESEM principles will balance, and build upon, significant continuing activities linked to a sustainable infrastructure design such as sustainable building rules and practices for safety from natural, conscious and accidental hazards. Sustainable Inf rastructure designs scope is divided in four aspects-All principles and practices used in the life cycle analysis of all infrastructure organizations from urban and regional development, which mixes infrastructure systems, to those for essential materials and constituents and for process and maintenance-Involving the private sector establishments that create and maintain the practices used for infrastructure systems and whose affiliates put in place these practices-Using severe life cycle analysis measures to deliver reliable signs of environmental, economic and social consequences and-Producing plans for application of top practices, development of practices to use current information, identify research needed to impression serious gaps in knowledge, and training for infrastructure specialists and operators. Figure 1 below represent the main types of infrastructure as well as main topics for research in design.Helping training platforms at college and universities in design, const ruction, engineering and planning, in integrating principles for sustainable infrastructure design in their curriculum, and reinforce K-12 training to develop a community understanding of sustainable infrastructure design and to invite qualified youth to infrastructure professions.FigureLaunch a lasting platform of research to deliver critically wanted information for enhancement of practices for sustainable infrastructure design. Involve the U.S. infrastructure society in a worldwide lying-in for sustainable infrastructure design. A summary of the scope of sustainable infrastructure design based of ESEM principles using the three spheres of sustainability which are environmental, social and economic. (figure 1)Figure preserve of Sustainable Infrastructure DesignSustainable infrastructure design influences all type of industries today. Even a superficial look at todays environmental defies aid us to recognize that sustainable infrastructure design is a great defy and a crucial one for that issue. The past of industrialization societies shapes us that design of infrastructure continuously leads economic development. A society must develop its infrastructure system to ease economic development and its aptitude to propagate on a sustainable foundation is subject to on how effectively it treats with environmental defies ascending from the procedure of building infrastructure.The benefits of sustainable infrastructure design increase through incorporating with buildings and across several infrastructure entities. For example, a landscaped exposed space can manage storm water, ease heat islands, deliver shading so that air conditioners need to run less often, and create a public facility. Sustainable infrastructure design can be effective in mixed-use localities. change land uses and structure types even out the demand for service. For example, people tend to use electricity, water and other utilities in the early AM and late PM, while commercial use heights in t he daytime. Diverse uses also create chances for resource re-use and interactions. The end result is urban localities that are more self-sufficient.Sustainable infrastructure design is efficient. For example, new wastewater treatment machinery combines biological processes with innovative process checking and control to improve efficiency, from both energy and treatment outlooks.There is a indispensableness to assume a consciousness determination to inform one and all to sustainability and the necessity to improve infrastructure system that can resist a show of sustainability. Its essential to implement a general tactic that should include sustainable infrastructure design growth guidelines and strategies. It should consider eco-efficiency conceptions and comprise systems related to water economy and control. The methodology should also be comprehensive of public utility services such as mass theodolites and production of power. The Federal Government and lawmakers should think about a sustainability financial plan that would offer more incentives for use of minimal natural resources and encourage investments in sustainable infrastructure designs.64% of Americans are abandoned to pay more nowadays for a national sustainable infrastructure that is energy-efficient and less inefficient in order to save money and resources in the upcoming, up from 58 percent last November. About 96% of Americans approve that all new infrastructures should be sustainable designs. Whether its on transportation amenities, like highways and bridges, or in buildings, were discovering that sustainability has turned to be a requirement for many agencies nowadays who are expecting sustainable structures. Nevertheless of the method, most of the US sees the importance in sustainable infrastructure design as an initiative. About76% senses that large-scale infrastructure expansions with sustainability in mind are a significant investment for future generations. The necessity for more we ll-organized and flexible transportation systems to provision the nations economy and class of life remains to be a main concern in the US.At the same time, climate change, power security, diminish natural resources, and queries about continuing transportation financing increase fears about the lasting practicality of our present methods to designing, constructing and maintaining our infrastructure. The transportation industrys development to sustainable practices is being led by political and the public, which is asking the industry to get closer with those that, are further advanced in sustainability. The U.S. transportation organizations are attaining sustainability in two methods -Developing design and construction practices taking more in consideration natural resources, and applying practices that decrease greenhouse gas emissions. In the construction industry, old highways materials are frequently recycled and reused in new highway asphalt and concrete. Reflective orange bar rels made of recycled plastic are placed in construction zones nowadays instead of battery-powered flashers.Sustainable infrastructure design practices can offer the data and information needed to make critical resolution, manage risk more efficiently, and eventually work in the direction of sustainable goals. However, sustainable infrastructure design plays a crucial significant part in assisting to generate a sustainable community. Sustainable infrastructure design practices permit us to frequently improve and launch improved control for sustainability. Sustainability today is measured using a diversity of signs, standards, reviews, guides, accounting and describe organizations, which can be applied at all scales. Some of these measurements, principally the environmental ones, are already based on assessable measurements. These include the nervous strain Quality Index, the Environmental Vulnerability Index. Other measurements such as the Corruption Perception Index, the Educatio n Index, and the Happy Planet Index are more socio-economic, in nature, and are often based on a combination of assessable and qualitative measurements. Regardless of the kind of measurement used to assess sustainability, they are all based on some sort of quantitative measurements, and data analysis techniques.ConclusionsThe purposes of this research paper on sustainable infrastructure design is be to bring awareness to the engineering community to keep a sustainable design in mind when design, planning and construction of new infrastructure systems. There is an great need for research activities related to both new and existing sustainable infrastructure design. New types of sustainable infrastructure design have to be substantial which will need less use of resources in the construction phase, more energy efficient buildings, new types of sustainable infrastructure design for construction and supply of power and for transport and communication. There is also a necessity for a m ore efficient use of resources by development of new sustainable materials, new construction principles and methods and by recycling infrastructure materials using ESEM principles. Also using life cycle assessments and costing to optimized infrastructure prices. Implementing and developing and promoting sustainable infrastructure design at all level in our society will have a great positive impact in the environment, social benefit and economic growth while preserving our ecosystems.
Tuesday, June 4, 2019
Allogeneic MCSs to make Cartilage for Knee Function
Allogeneic MCSs to make Cartilage for Knee FunctionINTRODUCTION 1.1 What is osteoarthritis? articular cartilage is a highly resilient hya occupancy meander composed of chondrocytes and surrounded by extra carrelular inter mobile phoneular substance present in a phrase which act as shock absorber, protects the attires from the friction and wear and helps in smooth move manpowert of the joint (Bhumiratana et al. 2014). Osteoarthritis is a disease of joint where overleap of cartilage causes musculoskeletal pain and labor of the movement or disability of the joint for the tolerant. (Ahmed and Hincke, 2010) (Duthey, 2015).Reasons for cartilage damage ar The impact / blow caused during sport activities or accidentWear and tear because of overuse of a joint (Observed in elderly people)Lack of movement (Medical News Today, 2017)Figure No.1. Osteoarthritis Affected portionImage Source www.osteoosteoOsteoarthritisresearchuk.orgOsteoarthritis can affect any joint present in the body. As the knee-joint Osteoarthritis is the most common type of Osteoarthritis, in this report, we leave discuss about knee-joint Osteoarthritis only.Tibiofemoral and patellofemoral be the two articular surfaces that the knee consists of. As it can be seen in the below image, the damaged cartilage, reduces the initiative between joint and friction is generated between the bones which ultimately results in bone erosion and causes muscle pain or inflammation or restriction to the movement.Figure No.2. Osteoarthritis affected KneeImage Source http//www.bupa.co.uk/health-information/directory/o/OsteoarthritisOsteoarthritis is estimated to affect 250 million people worldwide. Osteoarthritis live oners include men and women, children and adults. And according to World Health Organization, 30% of men and women over the age of 65 have Osteoarthritis (Woolf and Pfleger, 2003). Worldwide, 9.6% of men and 18.0% of women over the age of 60 eld have symptomatic Osteoarthritis. Approximately 8 0% of those with Osteoarthritis go forth have limitations in movement, and 25% cannot perform their major activities of daily life (Duthey, 2015).Figure No.3. prevalence of Osteoarthritis of KneeImage Source Burden of major musculoskeletal conditions, Bulletin of the WHO 20031.2 Treatments available for Osteoarthritis There are various ways to bring round Osteoarthritis when it is at the initial level, such(prenominal) as Exercise and weight lossBracingMedicationViscosupplementationNutritional supplements (Duthey, 2015).But when it becomes incurable by accomplishment and medication, surgical operations must be performed. Surgical procedures include Debridement i.e. Smoo thereforeing of the cartilage using surgical instrumentsMarrow Stimulation, a treatment which helps in regrowth of cartilage in the joint (but this process is slight reliable) (Treatment Options for Osteoarthritis in the Knee, 2017).Mosaicplasty, a process where the cartilage from some other joint of body is us ed. But this process has sizing limitations (Medical News Today, 2017).Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation, a treatment in which a sm all part of no-load bearing cartilage is removed from the joint of the patient by Arthroscopy, regrown and compute in the laboratory and then implanted back in the body by a procedure called arthrotomy. (Cartilage Repair, 2017) (Ahmed and Hincke, 2010) (Duthey, 2015).Even though the Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation seems useful and easy, it has many disadvantages such as The patients cartilage sample must be removed by a medical procedure, marked/tagged and treat independently just like blood sample.This treatment solicits big Logistics and Supply Chain.It conducts a lot of time (approximately 6 weeks) for cells to multiply. Hence, till then the patient forget suffer from pain (Peretti et al. 2000).1.3 Proposed Treatment for Osteoarthritis All these problems can be solved by Allogeneic Human Mesenchymal origin cellular phone. For autologous transplant donor and receiver are same, whereas for allogeneic transplant, the donor and the receiver are different. The selection of the donor must be done carefully cause if the tissue type, i.e. HLA (Human Leukocyte Antigens) doesnt match, the patients body will treat the transplanted pipe organ or tissue as a foreign body. It might result in GVHD i.e. Graft Vs Host Disease. It is a plunkal immune system solution against stem cell transplant (Si et al. 2011).Selection of donor for allogeneic transplant Syngeneic (i.e. Twins) It is the perfect HLA match, but very few people have a twin.HLA- matched relative (sibling) It is the guerilla preferred option as HLA will be closely matched.HLA-matched unrelated donor, it can be possible to find a donor whose HLA matches to the patient.HLA-mismatched family member, even though the HLA doesnt match, it has great chance that patients body may accept it.Umbilical cord blood, stem cells retrieved during birth of the patient and preserved in a cell bank. It will be safest of all but stem cells must be available (Flomenberg et al. 2004).Hence, allogeneic implant will make sure that the patient wont have to endure two medical procedures, as seen in autologous chondrocyte implantation.1.4 What are HMSCs?HMSC means Human Mesenchymal Stem cellular telephones. They are multipotent cells, which have the ability to transform into bone, muscle, fat or cartilage, etc. upon the proper simulation of providing environmental conditions in the laboratory. They have potential for regeneration (Si et al. 2011) (Li, LHeureux and Elisseeff, 2011) (Wei, 2013).Figure No.4. Potential of MSCsImage Source http//www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/241215.phpFigure No.5. Mesenchymal Stem CellsImage Source http//www.cytopeutics.com/IntroductionOfStemCells.htmlFor knee restoration, cartilage cells are postulate. Hence, the MSCs will be simulated for cartilage development. MSCs exists in almost all tissues. These cells can be soft encountere d from bone marrow, adipose tissue, cord cells and molar cells, fetal liver, muscle, and lung (Ahmed and Hincke, 2014) (Si et al. 2011).1.5 Product delivery to the Patient For blood transfusion, the blood group and presence of Rh factor is look into and the matching blood is introduced into the body. Similarly, after checking the tissue (HLA) match, the best matching cells are chosen and regrown exponentially in the controlled environment of a laboratory. When the required number of cells, shape, and sizing is achieved, the cartilage is implanted into the patient via an open joint surgery named arthrotomy. This implanted cartilage will function exactly as that of the superior cartilage. This cartilage will function properly for approximately 10 years (Ahmed and Hincke, 2010).1.7 Functioning of the product in the patients body Since, the HLA was matched, and the cartilage is manufacture using MSCs which has the same functional properties and characteristics that of the original car tilage, the function of the joint will return to normal. There wont be any complication after the treatment and that graft will be true by the body as a part of it, it wont be treated as a foreign body.MANUFACTURING FEASIBILITY REVIEW 2.1 Current Manufacturing engineering science and Scope for Future Currently, the knee restoration is done via other surgical procedures. But because of those procedures have many limitations and they give only temporary relief, allogeneic Mesenchymal Stem Cell therapy will replace them in the coming time. Mesenchymal Stem Cell therapy is currently under development. Various tests are being performed on them in the laboratory (Ahmed and Hincke, 2010).First, the bone marrow or adipose tissue or cord sample is collected from the donor. Then the mesenchymal stem cells are separated out from other cells, such as fat or muscle by centrifugation or apheresis. These two hardness separation processes are feasible only for liquid. For the extraction from so lid tissues, the slices of tissue are digested by the enzymes such as trypsin or collagenase. It breaks the bonding of cells i.e. the extracellular matrix (ECM) that holds the cells. Hence, the cell line is found (Li, LHeureux and Elisseeff, 2011).Then the cells are harvested. During the cell nuance process, there are various parameters that need to be monitored, little inconsistency will result in subnormal product or it might be just a waste of product. Temperature, humidity, oxygen, pH level of the cell culture reagent, nutrient supply and waste removal are the physical parameters and cell figuring and cell viability are the biological parameters that need to be monitored (Schwamb, Puskeiler and Wiedemann, 2015).Once the desired number of cells is achieved, boundary for CMB (Condensed Mesenchymal Cell Bodies) is set. Then the cells are condensed to increase the seeding density as the cartilage requires higher seeding density. Then the fusion of the CMB happens. Now this fused C MB is pressurized against a porous decellularized bone matrix to create dense cellular region i.e. cartilage (Bhumiratana et al. 2014). As the knee joint is a mechanical tissue, physical stimulation is needed for its development. However, excessive stimulation can runway to cartilage damage (Ahmed and Hincke, 2010). Cartilage then sticks to the surface of that bone matrix and takes its shape while growing around it. Then it is removed from the bone matrix to implant into the knee joint of the patient (Bhumiratana et al. 2014).Figure No.6. Condensed Mesenchymal Cell Bodies FusionImage Source http//www.pnas.org/content/111/19/6940.abstractCurrently, only culture plates and culture flasks are being used for allogeneic Mesenchymal Stem Cells as it is still in testing arrange (Schwamb, Puskeiler, and Wiedemann, 2015).Figure No.7. Culture flasks and platesImage Source https//www.shutterstock.comBut monitoring all these parameters becomes very hard when using flasks and plates. And the cells need to be shifted into bigger containers frequently. Also, flasks and plates are not useful for mass production because of size limitation and economic consideration. Hence, a device named bioreactor can replace them and still perform all those tasks efficiently.Figure No.8. Bioreactor for mass Cell CultureImage Source http//www.bioc.rice.edu/bios576/nih_bioreactor/NDL_Bioreactor%20Page.htmlIt is a container which is feasible for twain aerobic and anaerobic cell culture and can be used for suspended as well as immobilized cells (Sandhya Anand, 2017). It can be operated in batch, supply batch and continuous mode. As MSCs are surface anchorage dependent, the extra agitation or stirring might result in damage to the tissue. And the MSCs require oxygen to grow, so it will be an aerobic, immobilized, batch production bioreactor. (Martin, Wendt and Heberer, 2004) (Oragui, Nannaparaju and Khan, 2011).2.2 Challenges in mass production of MSCs Large scale in vitro expansion of MSC s is very complex because maintaining cells quality attributes such as identity, potency, purity and safety is extremely hard. It is hard to monitor that the cells are not undergoing any quality changes while expansion and harvesting.another(prenominal) challenge is obtaining required no of cells and their recovery.MSCs are not suspension type, but anchorage dependent therefore the surface area for anchorage and proliferation must be taken into account.As allogeneic treatments are supposed to be for a lot of people, hence the required no of cells must be extremely large.There are 3 major and 3 minor types of HLAs in MHC Class I and 3 major and 2 minor types of HLAs in MHC Class II. So, there are lots of variants to manufacture and maintain for the cartilage manufacturer.2.3 Clinical Demand for Dosage Even though there are 250 million people suffering from Osteoarthritis and 3.6% of them are suffering from knee Osteoarthritis i.e. 9 million people. More than 600,000 knee replacement s are performed each year in the United States alone (A land in Motion, 2017). In UK 160,000 knee replacement surgeries are performed every year (Joint replacement statistics, 2017).As the cartilage manufactured in the laboratory exhibit almost similar properties that to the natural cartilage, it is expected to last approximately 50-60 years (i.e. Average human life) if there are no unexpected tragedies. Hence, once treated properly, the patient wont have to worry about the joint in his life again.2.4 Supply Chain for Product Figure No.9. Formation of Master Cell cussFirst the cell line is chosen for culturing, it can be a well-known cell line or a newly found cell line. After certain passages, when the desired number of cells is achieved, the Master Cell Bank will be established. In this case, many Master Cell Banks are needed as there are many types of tissues. Then one portion of master cell bank will be used for research purpose, i.e. the working cell bank and the rest will be cryopreserved for future use. Good manufacturing practice protocol should be followed during cell culturing.Figure No.10. Clinical Process for Cell CulturingThe working cell bank will be used for manufacturing of cells for mass production after testing is performed. Several production runs (i.e. enactments) will be performed to obtain the required number of cells. Then the cells will be cryopreserved in central storage and distributed via local channels until there is a patient who needs them.2.5 chance Assessment The main aim of risk assessment is to prevent transmission of diseases, and avoid harm to individuals and the environment. In many countries, the performance of risk assessment is a legal requirement. (University of Manitoba)RiskImpactProbability of OccurrenceMitigation StrategyTissue/cell originRejection of CellsLowThorough testing of cell lineLack of Donor HistoryTransmission of DiseaseLowChoosing a donor carefullyMismatch of HLAGraft vs Host DiseaseIntermediate too -careful matching of HLAEnvironmental ChangesChange in cell QualityHighClose monitoring of environmental conditionsPlasma Derived MaterialCell line taint with unwanted cellsHighProper filtration of MSCs(Herberts, Kwa and Hermsen, 2011)2.6 Biosafety Measure Depending upon the as the product is human derived, Biosafety Level 2 practices, equipment and facilities are chosen. It is most suitable for clinical, diagnostic and teaching purposes. science laboratory personnel must maintain hygiene while entering and exiting the lab. Decontaminated of potentially infectious material must be done before disposal, either by a disinfectant, or by autoclaving. Personal protective equipment is only required when there is a possibility of exposure to hazardous material. The laboratory must be isolated from the general building. Laboratory personnel must be trained in handling pathogenic agents. Access to the laboratory should be limited during the work. certain(p) procedures in which infectious th ermobaric bombs or splashes may be created biological safety cabinets or other physical containment equipment should be used and the rest can be performed on the open bench. Biosafety level 2 is suitable for indigenous moderate-risk agents. This includes various microbes that cause mild disease to humans, or are difficult to contract via aerosol in a lab setting, human derived blood, body fluid, tissues, or primary cell lines (Inc, 2017).PROCESS MAP AND CELL GROWTH ANALYSIS 3.1 Process routine Figure No.11. Process Map for HMSC TherapyProcess Description Cell lines are created/chosen for each type of tissue (HLA).Shipping of the tissue sample to cell therapy processing facility.HMSC isolation and culturing in culture chambers (manual production using culture flask or culture plate) or bioreactor is performed.Fresh HMSCs are then tested for various parameters such as identity, potency, purity and safety, the modifications are done.Aliquoting of HMSC samples (i.e. Master Cell Bank) i s done.Freezing and storage at -196 C in Vapor unruffled Nitrogen (i.e. Cryopreservation) for future reference and use is done (Inc, 2017).Cells are thawed i.e. their temperature is brought up to normal room temperature and further increased to 37 C (Normal embody Temperature) for best cell growth result (Inc, 2017).Cell characterization per release Criteria for Thawed HMSCsExpansion of thawed HMSCs using an incubator and/or bioreactor for production.Activation of HMSCs into last(a) cell therapy product.Shipping of final product to medical treatment centre.Implantation of the cartilage into the patient by open joint surgery, i.e. arthrotomy (Harel, 2013).Cell Growth analysis As there are many types of tissues (HLA), testing for all of them must be performed and validated. Hence, the whole process will be repeated several clock for each type of cells. enter Data Desired seeding density= 1 million/ml distance of Passage= 72 hoursDoubling Time= 36 hoursEfficiency= 80% (Average eff iciency)Input Vial contains= 1.00E+09 cells treat per Patient= 1.00E+09 cells =1 vial of doseGrowth Rate= Ln (2) /Doubling Time= 0.019254Seeding Density1,000,000Passage Duration72Doubling Time36Efficiency0.8Input Vial1.00E+09Growth Rate0.019254 build 115PatientsFlaskDose Per Patient1.00E+09T25MCB CreationReal SAInput holy person SA fruitNoteT75Thaw1.00E+09800.008.00E+08All Flask of Same SizeT175Passage 17006.40E+082560.002.56E+094*T175T500Passage 225002.05E+098192.008.19E+095*T500T650Passage 378006.55E+0926214.402.62E+106*T1300T1300Passage 4260002.10E+1083886.088.39E+101*T26000T3250T6500T26000MCBs Created21.51Equivalent Vials83.89Cells Per 5-Layer flask3.90E+09Phase 1Real SAInputIdeal SAOutputNoteThaw3.99E+093195.663.20E+09Passage 130002.56E+0910226.111.02E+106*T500Passage 291008.18E+0932723.563.27E+107*T1300Dosages3.27E+012.62E+01For Phase 1 Testing21 Master Cell Banks will be created in a 5-layer flask (T3250). It would be equivalent to the size of 83.89 stimulus vials after 4 pa ssages. From those 21 cell banks, 1 will be thawed and the rest will be cryopreserved. That 1 cell bank will be chosen as working cell bank and will be harvested for production.During Phase 1, treating 30 patients will be the target. Hence, 30 vials of doses should be manufactured during build one.Every time 20% loss of cells is considered while changing the flask.And During passages, exponential growth will take place. Formula for Exponential Growth is The Ideal surface area is calculated by Flask size was kept uniform during every passage. And Actual Surface Area was always chosen less than Ideal Surface Area to maintain the desired density and environment.Flask of capacity 5-Layer was chosen for MCB creation.Calculations for MCB,Number of doses,After successful testing of phase 1, phase 2 will begin where 300 patients will be treated. So, 300 vials of cells will be required.PHASE 2Real SAInputIdeal SAOutputNoteThaw3.99E+093195.663.20E+09Passage 130002.56E+0910226.111.02E+106*T50 0Passage 291008.18E+0932723.563.27E+107*T1300Passage 3325002.62E+10104715.391.05E+115*T6500Passage 41040008.38E+10335089.263.35E+114*T26000Dosages3.35E+02For Phase 2 TestingAfter successful testing of phase 1 and phase 2, phase 3 will begin when mass production will start and 100s of 1000s of people will be treated with allogeneic HMSC derived cartilage.PHASE 3Real SAInputIdeal SAOutputNoteThaw3.99E+093195.663.20E+09Passage 130002.56E+0910226.111.02E+106*T500Passage 291008.18E+0932723.563.27E+107*T1300Passage 3325002.62E+10104715.391.05E+115*T6500Passage 41040008.38E+10335089.263.35E+114*T26000Passage 53120002.68E+111072285.631.07E+1212*T26000Passage 610660008.58E+113431314.003.43E+1241*T26000Passage 734060002.75E+1210980204.811.10E+13131*T26000Dosages1.10E+04For Phase 3Since, there are 7 passages the process to manufacture 11000 vials will require approximately 25 (considered an extra time for changing flask) days. And at that rate 15 batches will be produced per year and approxima tely 165000 patients can be treated per year.As there are 6 types of tissues (HLA) total number of patients treated will be 990000 approximately. It will be equivalent to 11% of global demand. employ Bioreactor for Phase 3 Instead of using Culture flasks or plates, a bioreactor can be used for cell culturing. To check which of these two techniques will be more efficient, all the parameters are kept same. And total time of 7 passages will be considered as one passage time for bioreactor.Passage Duration504Doubling Time36PHASE
Monday, June 3, 2019
Water Conflicts and Dispute Resolution
pissing Conflicts and Dispute ResolutionTHE LARSON . KING SYMPOSIUM WATER, CATALYST OF LIFE AND STRIFE A THREAT TO certification OR A VITAL OPPORTUNITY TO FOSTER COOPERATION? ARTICLE INTERNATIONAL JOINT COMMISSION WATER CONFLICTS AND DISPUTE RESOLUTIONSUMMARYThe dish away was created in 1909 and although it subprograms a bottom up draw near to reach consensus, the documentary conclusion making is d oneness by the two g all everyplacenments the testimonials argon made by nation tout ensembley plant commissioners, and the study groups be made up of adept experts from government and elected or billed officials who fo down the stairs decisions in the traditional way, where worldly hit notice and citizen intimacy is at best advisory in character and not necessarily meaningful. Most recently, Lake Mead and Lake Lanier be two object lessons of the numerous pending conflicts that focus on competing irrigate demands. a good deal these problems capture real conflict s because unanticipated channelizes in necessitate, dis reasons mooting the costs and values inherent in the constitution frontities, and dissatisfaction with the benefits received by whatsoever participants compared to the benefits obtained by separate agonistic interests. In most cases, the deviation liquidation utensils are rather basic and embroil some spend a penny of consultation, facilitation, intermediation and, in some modified cases, adjudication or arbitrament. Waterways and Boundary Disputes Water and boundary divergences and worldwide treaties are not new to the fall in States. He understood the importance of good transaction betwixt the unite States and Canada, and he believed that one central aspect of that relationship was the leveltual resolution of disputes arising under the Boundary Waters Treaty. Grey pressed Canadas lead to appoint guidanceers to the newly established internationalist Waterways Commissions he boostd Secretary of State Elihu Root to participate in discussions and duologues with Canada, and to establish a titular ongoing mechanism for Canada and the U.S. to utilize for resolve boundary disputes. The confederation branch employ by the IJC encourages participants to better ascertain boundary peeing disputes and issues.I. BACKGROUNDWater is in truth special. It is necessitate for survival. The nature of irrigate and its general availability is practically taken for granted and only recently sustain industrialized nations of the world taken note of hand of the say-so problems wet system supply shortages might create for communities, product linees and governments. A supply of clean-living urine is not enough. There is a need for accessible, inexpensive, safe, and usable urine. Emerging nations generally turn in a better understanding of the importance piddle plays in health, hygiene, education, agriculture, economic development, and peace. The United Nations estimates that by 2 025 almost 2.7 gazillion people entrust shit loathly irrigate scarcity, and contaminated water supplies will contri excepte to millions of deaths annually. n2Approximately 1.1 one million million million people in the world wishing adequate water and virtually 2.6 billion are without adequate sanitation. n3 In addition, only 1% of the worlds unspoiled water is usable. n4 The most apparent needs for water endure be seen in India, mainland China and Africa, nevertheless these examples are not isolated. India and Chinas skyrocketing economic growth sustain diverted old priorities and added new demands for earthshaking amounts of additional water. n5 Other countries in southeastern America, part of Asia, Europe, and North America also speculate increasing demands for water. Population growth contributes to the rising demand for water, and the impact of world wide droughts caused by the ever-changing surroundings has made parts of China and areas of Africa, Australia a nd the United States extremely vulnerable. Examples of dependence on dwindling water supplies are easily found. Declining levels of water in reservoirs, fresh water lakes and rivers are compounded by declining rainfall. n6 Similar sides can also be found in the western and southeast areas of the United States.Changing world trends, much(prenominal) as movements from the Northeast and Midwest United States to Atlanta, Phoenix, Las Vegas and parts of California and Texas, contribute to the water shortage problem. Rising energy demands because of urban/suburban growth, ratified decisions and *595 continually increasing agricultural demands have also raised awareness and understanding of the importance of maintaining adequate water supplies, preserving heights prize water militia and managing the exceptional water supply as effectively as possible. n7 In addition, thither has been an increase awareness of the interdependence communities and countries have toward one an an opposi te(prenominal)(prenominal) regarding the rescue and use of fresh water the wearment and protection of existing water basins and groundwater supplies and the conservation practices and best practices relating to water management.Conflicts over water supplies are not new. In the United States, early conflicts arose over competing agricultural and mining uses later, residents in the Southwest fought in state and federal courts as well as at the administrative result level over the distribution of water from the Colorado River. Currently, Las Vegas is in several disputes regarding its need for water. The situation in Las Vegas invokes the problem demonstrated during the early 1900s, when Los Angeles acquired the water rights in the Owens Valley which left a wasteland of a former agricultural region. n8 Most recently, Lake Mead and Lake Lanier are two examples of the many pending conflicts that focus on competing water demands. n9Current international examples of disputes over water u sage and supplies can be found in conflicts arising in and around the Jordan, Saskatchewan and Rhone Rivers. n10 Other areas where pertains have arisen regarding the deliverance of significant water supplies include the area surrounding the Guarani Aquifer, which covers an area greater than Great Britain, France and Spain, and provides a water source for more than twenty million people. n11 some other example is the general reference of the ongoing problem of the Rio Grande or Rio Bravo that is a lifeline for millions of people in the southwestern United States and northern Mexico. The regions aquifers are organism depleted from overuse, the new demands created by *596 changes in the demographics, the rapid expansion of Maquiladoras and the increased demands for greater agricultural production. n12Disputes over water among competing interests can be explained by its fantastic ability to provide a foundation for life and society. The finite nature of water can also explain water disputes at twain the local anesthetic and international level. Additional conflicts whitethorn, however, arise and cause change surface more problematic as water wrenchs a commodity that is controlled by international corporations that can buy, portion out and trade this product for their own advantage. Currently, about ten corporations control a large portion of the worlds water supply. They represent a $ 400 billion business and will at long last contribute significant national wealth for some countries and cause other water scarce countries to be dependent on, and even debtor nations to, those companies controlling the worlds fresh water. n13 Some experts have suggested that water and the demand for fresh water will be what oil was during the last century and the lack of fresh water may generate such(prenominal)(prenominal) an intense concern and political discontent that future wars might be fought over trans-b rules of order disputes involving water. n14 Many governm ents and companies have begun pursuance ownership or control of existing and potential sources of fresh water. Some governments are planning and arming dams and reservoirs to store needed water supplies even if such action might be detrimental to those down river from the projects, and other efforts have been undertaken to control ground water within a countrys boundaries. Recently, the Governor of novel Mexico, a presidential candidate, suggested there was a need for a national water policy that would divert fresh water from existing sources to those states that had an inadequate water supply. The design was not well received by the leaders and people from states having adequate water re allots, and it died a quick and quiet demise. Several other overtures have occurred from both(prenominal) government and business interests seeking water resources from the upper Midwest and Canada one proposal even suggested taking water from the Great Lakes by the tankful. n15A. Water insur ance Programs, Problems and ReportsRecognition of the potential problems returning from competing demands has created several responses. One response has been the Darwinian sexual climax of self- survival or survival of the fittest (those who have the water control those who dont have water). A second advancement attempts *597 to create and manage water policies that coordinate competing demands such as residential, agricultural and commercial needs. Attempts are also made to vestibular sense rural, urban environmental and political demands. This second approach requires the use of non-homogeneous experts, community representation, research and a richly degree of transparency regarding popular decision making.The development of public policy requires the involvement of those with competing interests and values regarding water usage, accurate and dependable data from which options can be evaluated and decisions made, and finally community support found on increased awareness and individual buy-in of the policy choices or recommendations. The likelihood of policy failure or non submission with policy luffives ordinarily results from lack of duty or involvement of the allow government agency or body, too little funding, failure to balance all interests, unclear rules or turn taillines and inappropriate or toothless dispute resolution mechanisms. n16Specific problems that arise concerning development of water policy are data gaps, or incomplete information the difficulty of reflecting real direct and indirect costs in pricing improper management of water resources caused by failing to include all jurisdictions affected by the appropriate landmark failure to enforce existing regulations or lack of enforceable rules incomplete intergovernmental oversight of associated issues and shortsightedness in policy related decision-making which fails to balance competing interests. n17 Often these problems cause real conflicts because unanticipated changes in n eeds, disagreements regarding the costs and values inherent in the policy priorities, and dissatisfaction with the benefits received by some participants compared to the benefits obtained by other competitive interests. Problems may also arise because political influence and pressures that alter the political landscape dedicate compromise difficult or impossible. In some cases water policy problems may be alleviated by new funding sources, different rule interpretations, or recent discriminative decisions. Other influences that remove or curtail related conflicts might be the introduction of new technology, changing market conditions, ameliorate conservation practices or improved collaboration among the competing interest groups. n18In order to respond to the real or potential problem, a well thought-out water policy should be followed. Successful implementation of water policy programs require, accord to the International Joint Commission 1) accountability based on predetermin ed obligations, 2) meeting performance standards, 3) accomplishing results based on the means and the agreed upon expectation. n19 The end result of increased accountability should be greater *598 compliance with policy guidelines, greater collaboration, and cooperation in the midst of governmental bodies, NGOs and private interests. In order to insure successful compliance with water policy programs it is also essential that a monitor system be established to go over and evaluate the activities of the program and its ultimate success or value. A program of evaluation would include a system of measurements or indicators that establish conditions and goals to be accomplished. n20 In addition, a communicateing process should be created that would encompass economic, political, companionable and technical issues in a credible convictionly and transparent manner. n21 A comprehensive supervise system is not in itself sufficient, therefore it is inevitable to develop an assessment process that periodically catchs the submitted reports and seriously evaluates the policy plan and implementation and makes recommendations to vary, correct or amend the current program to satisfy needs, such as economic, social and political changes. A report should wherefore be made easy to the public and those impacted by the water policy. n22The report should pay off out the policy objectives, goals and resources ready(prenominal) in the implementation of the policy. It should also calculate options and alternatives to the existing policy and an explanation as to why recommended actions were taken. This report should also consider the monetary and environmental impact of the various actions. There might also be a report as to the number and types of conflict that have arisen in regard to the policy. Finally, the report and related documentation should be made available to the public.B. Policy ConflictsThe issue of who will control the water supply raises a signifier of oral sexs that often create conflicts. Who can use the water supply, to whom does the water supply belong to and what rights attach to a particular body of water or the owner of that water? Other questions that arise regarding control of water may include can water be a commodity and therefore be sell to the highest bidder without concern for personal needs what is the impact on future generations, or what is the value of water to the general public? Can water be defend under the Public Trust Doctrine because it is, or can be argued that it is like air, a basic necessity of life? n23If one uses the Commons argument, then some any water supply that is managed by a governmental body for the benefit of the public could be included in the doctrine however, if water is not treated as part of the *599 Commons the survival of individuals in society may be threatened. The Commons argument relies on past judicial decisions rendition property rights and property law. n24Other conflicts m ay also arise in regard to the water supply. Environmental concerns, economic benefits, the equitable distribution of resources, public participation and partisan decision-making are only a few examples. As we examine the existing water policy dispute mechanisms, it will be important to withdraw that, because of the wide variety of problems, there may not be a single approach or method capable of resolving all water-related conflicts. Since water supplies have a regional or even greater impact, we should look to dispute mechanisms that encourage wide public participation, allow for public consensus among participants and which serve to enlighten and inform the public about water demand, water conservation techniques and current alternatives to water policy. Special attention should be effrontery the dispute techniques used in international water conflicts between the United States and Canada, and the United States and Mexico.C. Water Policy Dispute MechanismsDisputes over water h ave been reported since the makening of put down history. A war over a water-related issue occurred over 4,500 years ago, and during the last 1,200 years there have been about 3,600 water related international treaties. n25 Since 1870 there have been 145 treaties to manage water, of which 124 are bilateral and twenty-one are multilateral. n26 The principal focus of these agreements has been related to hydropower, but there are other agreements that concern themselves with water distribution for consumption, industrial usage, navigation, pollution and flood control. n27Many of the treaties provide for exchange of data between the signatories of the treaty. This effort provides an opportunity for program administrators and technical experts to strain relationships and interdependence within their working group. Some conditions of these water resource treaties include a formula or methodology for allocating water within the agreement or by the use of a board or governing body body the use of economic benefits for one or more of the treaty participants recognition that the water resource is unique and must be given special consideration in determining the use and distribution of the water in question and usually downstream participants are given clearer and more specific protection. n28 Treaty participants often negotiate a variety of non-water linkages in their *600 agreements relating to political concessions, exchange of high quality useable water and access to capital and pollution control mechanisms. n29 Many of the international agreements, about 55%, provide for some form of monitoring process, and some 50% of the treaties provide for some form of dispute resolution process which could include an advisory council, a third neutral party or a designated organization such as the United Nations. n30 In most cases, the dispute resolution mechanisms are rather basic and include some form of consultation, facilitation, mediation and, in some limited cases, ad judication or arbitrament. Historically, most water treaties established a hierarchy of uses when negotiating water agreements. Generally, navigation is given priority over other preferences, but today most agreements do not list the order of preferences. Instead, they indicate the options or alternative uses for the water. Usually the preference list would include domesticated and municipal uses, industrial uses, navigation, recreational uses, agricultural uses, and energy uses. n31II. INTERNATIONAL APPROACHES TO ENVIRONMENTAL DISPUTESA. Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA)When disputes arise over issues addressed in water-related treaties, the mechanism used in resolving the conflict is often an advisory board, an ad hoc or permanent commission, or a governmental body. These bodies have various levels of part and frequently must have approval from a national or regional government before a decision can be implemented. Until recently there had been no unified forum to which stat es, NGOs, individual citizens and corporate or international groups could turn for resolution of their disputes. n32 The Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) may now, however, be used to resolve water disputes.When taken together, the PCA and the Optional Rules for Environmental Conflicts provide interest parties the opportunity to reach an agreement that is acceptable and capable of harmonizing the needs of divers(prenominal) interests, cultures and values. n33 In addition, the PCA approach provides decision makers who are experienced in environmental matters, who understand the impact of these decisions on the environment and who need to maintain a high degree of confidentiality regarding national security *601 issues and proprietary data with a process to produce decisions in a measurely manner. n34 The PCA Options are tailored curiously for environmental disputes and provide some useful features such as detailed rules for arbitrement and placation, the use of environmental e xperts as witnesses, and a process that aids in the facilitation of disputes and the monitoring of any settlement agreement. n35 Currently, over ninety countries have adopted the PCA Environmental Arbitration and Conciliation Rules and have contributed to improving the possibility of environmental disputes universe colonized more quickly and with greater participant satisfaction. n36The PCA Environmental Rules fill a gap in the decision-making process for environmental disputes that had not been previously filled. The Rules reflect a broad international acceptance of at least two alternatives with defined rules which parties can use and be confident that they will be comprehend and given a fair hearing regarding their concerns. The Rules do not solve all the problems regarding environmental conflicts but they are a vast improvement over prior dispute mechanisms. The Rules now bring environmental dispute subprograms more closely in line with dispute mechanisms found in, for exampl e, investment treaties or the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL). n37Conflicts regarding the distribution of existing water supplies between treaty participants and/or regarding the order of allocation of water among competing users eventually become a public dispute. Governmental bodies are part of every public dispute and because of their involvement, these disputes take on different characteristics than private conflicts. Generally speaking, the public nature of a dispute means public participation, greater transparency, and possible political pressure. Public disputes are, however, similar to private disputes in that the dispute resolution mechanisms available to parties in conflict are the basic alternative dispute resolution options or derivatives of these options.B. Dispute Mechanism TechniquesThe two most common dispute resolution techniques are arbitration and mediation.Arbitration or non-binding arbitration occurs when two disputants refer thei r conflict to a third party decision-maker cognize as the arbitrator, who will constitute a decision which will generally be final, or only advisory in *602 non-binding arbitration. Usually arbitrations are the result of a prior contractual agreement, but arbitrations can also begin when the disputants agree to use the arbitration process to resolve a pending dispute. In arbitration or non-binding arbitration the parties take aim one or more arbitrators, who hear the case as presented by the representatives of the parties and then issue an award or advisory opinion. Most arbitration decisions cannot be appealed. Parties to an arbitration usually need to agree in advance to the arbitration format and the form of the arbitrators report. Arbitration provides parties with an opportunity to select an excellent good fact- nonpluser, who will generate an impartial opinion. It lifts problems associated with litigation and creates a binding decision to be followed by the parties. Non-bi nding arbitration may be valuable because it could provide a spry decision based on the recommendation of an expert. Parties may not want to use this type of arbitration if cost or timing is a problem. The arbitration process can often reduce conflicts between the parties and reduce the amount of discovery needed.intermediation is a facilitative process. Mediation is a rapidly suppuration technique that involves a neutral third party trained to assist the parties negotiating an agreement. The mediator has no independent authority and does not render a decision any decision must be reached by the parties themselves. some other definition of mediation refers to mediation being an art and not a science, therefore, the process reflects many different and rich options for dispute settlement. n38 One set of authors say mediation is a process in which an impartial third party acts as a catalyst to answer others constructively address and perhaps resolve, plan a transaction or define t he contours of a relationship. n39 Finally, Kimberlee Kovach says mediation is the intervention into a dispute or negotiation by an acceptable, impartial and neutral third party who has no authoritative decision- making power to assist disputing parties in voluntarily compass their own mutually acceptable settlement of issues in dispute. n40The mediation process is simple. The initial level begins with a preliminary review of the facts by the mediator. Mediation begins with an rise statement that describes the process and sets mutually agreeable ground rules. The second stage begins the fact-finding and is the time for the parties to present their case and to confront the issues. This is also the time when expelling may occur between the parties. During this stage positions are presented, the interests of the parties are discovered and basic agreement on possible solutions might be aired. The following stage includes a discussion of proposed settlement options, and the mediator must generate movement toward settlement if the parties are at an impasse. The final stage is *603 agreement between the parties and negotiating the call of the settlement agreement.Mediation can be described as facilitative, evaluative or transformative. The facilitative method encourages a problem solving approach to dispute resolution. This method requires the mediator to encourage mutual discussion, exchange of information and germinal intellects as to how the dispute might be solved. The facilitative method is intentional to build consensus. It is quite flexible in the implementation of the process, and it is the least adversarial between the parties. The evaluative method is focused on the resolution of the dispute. The mediator hears the arguments and then attempts to encourage a particular solution between the parties by using his or her skills, knowledge and expertise. This form of mediation may develop into a shuttle fragility approach where the mediator moves back an d forth between two rooms and the parties and their lawyers consider various proposals and counter proposals. The third method is a newer mediation approach known as transformative mediation. This method attempts to create a setting that will give the parties the opportunity to exercise their choice and to leave the final decision and right of resolving their conflict to themselves. Healing, replacation and the making of a lasting agreement are left to the parties and their individual abilities. The mediator in this approach performs the function of a guide or advisor during the process.Mediation is useful and likely to be successful if the parties have had an ongoing relationship. If cost is an issue, then mediation is the least pricy alternative. If one of the parties finds it necessary to express their emotions or if they get out of control during formal proceedings, then mediation is a workable solution. Mediation, because it is private and flexible, allows for the use of creat ive solutions and it may allow the parties to communicate more effectively with each other.Mediation can also be referred to as non-directive and directive mediation. Non- directive mediation describes how the mediators last in regard to their attempts to influence the parties. In this model the mediator avoids making judgments, recommending options and questioning statements and arguments. A directive mediation oriented mediator would express opinions, make proposals, altercate values, question positions and attempt to steer the parties to his or her solution.Prior to most arbitration or mediation efforts there is a period of discussion, consultation or negotiation that frequently results in a dispute being resolved, troubling actions modified or sticking points settled. Often these methods are ad hoc, informal and unstructured. The process that precedes formal or structured procedures is known as negotiation.Negotiation, unlike arbitration or mediation, does not require the servi ces of a third party neutral. Usually, the interested parties begin a conversation with one another when they believe there is a misunderstanding. Here they are seeking a benefit or improved situation *604 when compared to their current position or where they try to avoid further escalation of the initial conflict. Negotiation is a conflict resolution technique that settles disagreement and seeks to avoid or prevent future disputes.Consultation may precede a structured negotiation and is frequently used in major contract disputes. Because of the hammy growth of international trade and the development of the foundation Trade Organizations (WTO) four-part Dispute Settlement System, its use has increased greatly. Usually consultation is entered into voluntarily and is used to help the parties understand their dispute, how the parties see the issues, and to clarify the legal rights and claims of all parties. WTO records indicate that more than half of their cases are settled or abando ned during the consultation phase. n41 Consultation allows parties to modify their positions, change their understanding or to acquire new information that may influence their action or thinking. n42 Consultation is often voluntary but it may become obligatory if included as a contact clause or treaty requirement. Both negotiation and consultation are devices to encourage cooperation and their use, when mandated, functions as an anticipatory action to avoid or prevent the use of formal or structured dispute settlement mechanisms that are more costly and time consuming.Another possibility when international treaties or conventions are involved and parties to a dispute are not able to reconcile their differences though negotiations is the use of the safe(p) Offices of the governing body of the agreement. Generally, Good Offices means the office of the secretariat of the organization or body responsible for the implementation of the agreement. The use of Good Offices may be as simple as facilitating a conversation between the disputing parties or providing facilities for such a meeting. It may also include the provision of mediation or conciliation services or it may require the actual intervention by an international body. n43 The use of Good Offices has been a frequently used animal in international diplomacy and was integrated in the Hague Convention for the Pacific Settlement of International Disputes in 1907. More recently, similar language has been included in agreements creating the World Trade Organization and the Law of the Sea Convention.Disagreements at the international level often address issues and facts that the parties do not agree to or that they find nearly irreconcilable. When such an impasse occurs it is possible to seek the help of a board of inquiry or a fact-finding body commission to investigate and report findings *605 related to the disagreement. The commission option was initially an ad hoc undertaking that was formalized in the 1899 Hague Convention for the Pacific Settlement of Disputes. n44 The early commissions were established to examine issues in dispute such as when the U.S. battleship Maine was sunk, when the Russian Fleet fired on British fishing vessels in 1904, and when an American woman was killed in a Chilean sponsored car bombing in the United States. n45 These commissions and board inquiries are less frequently used now because other ADR techniques are available and parties are comfortable using them.Conciliation is another ADR method used to resolve international disputes. This method is similar to both mediation and arbitration. Conciliation as a process has been used for about eighty-five years, and over 200 bilateral treaties and many multilateral agreements have language enabling disputants to use this alternative. n46 The idea of conciliation commissions, a combination of inquiry commissions and conciliation, were actually used as early as 1914 but the concept has not become a twist proced ure in dispute resolution practice. n47 Conciliation requires a third party neutral to encourage the disputing parties to begin a dialogue with one another and to add up at a mutually agreeable resolution process. It also requires the neutral to examine the circumstances surrounding the conflict and, after an independent inquiry, make a recommendation based upon the evidence and information that has been discovered during the process of fact finding. n48 The parties are not required to accept the recommendation. Conciliation resembles mediation in its facilitative, non- adversarial and non-binding aspects but it follows formalities more like arbitration, such as investigation, evaluation and decision-making. n49 Conciliation has been successful in the few cases where it has been tried, and it provides benefits to the parties because they can reject any recommendation if they desire. n50 In addition,Water Conflicts and Dispute ResolutionWater Conflicts and Dispute ResolutionTHE LARS ON . KING SYMPOSIUM WATER, CATALYST OF LIFE AND STRIFE A THREAT TO SECURITY OR A VITAL OPPORTUNITY TO FOSTER COOPERATION? ARTICLE INTERNATIONAL JOINT COMMISSION WATER CONFLICTS AND DISPUTE RESOLUTIONSUMMARYThe process was created in 1909 and although it uses a bottom up approach to reach consensus, the real decision making is done by the two governments the recommendations are made by nationally appointed commissioners, and the study groups are made up of technical experts from government and elected or appointed officials who make decisions in the traditional way, where public comment and citizen engagement is at best advisory in nature and not necessarily meaningful. Most recently, Lake Mead and Lake Lanier are two examples of the many pending conflicts that focus on competing water demands. Often these problems cause real conflicts because unanticipated changes in needs, disagreements regarding the costs and values inherent in the policy priorities, and dissatisfaction with the b enefits received by some participants compared to the benefits obtained by other competitive interests. In most cases, the dispute resolution mechanisms are rather basic and include some form of consultation, facilitation, mediation and, in some limited cases, adjudication or arbitration. Waterways and Boundary Disputes Water and boundary disputes and international treaties are not new to the United States. He understood the importance of good relations between the United States and Canada, and he believed that one important aspect of that relationship was the eventual resolution of disputes arising under the Boundary Waters Treaty. Grey pressed Canadas leadership to appoint Commissioners to the newly established International Waterways Commissions he encouraged Secretary of State Elihu Root to participate in discussions and negotiations with Canada, and to establish a formal ongoing mechanism for Canada and the U.S. to utilize for resolving boundary disputes. The participation proc ess used by the IJC encourages participants to better understand boundary water disputes and issues.I. BACKGROUNDWater is very special. It is needed for survival. The nature of water and its general availability is often taken for granted and only recently have industrialized nations of the world taken note of the potential problems water shortages might create for communities, businesses and governments. A supply of fresh water is not enough. There is a need for accessible, inexpensive, safe, and usable water. Emerging nations generally have a better understanding of the importance water plays in health, hygiene, education, agriculture, economic development, and peace. The United Nations estimates that by 2025 nearly 2.7 billion people will experience severe water scarcity, and contaminated water supplies will contribute to millions of deaths annually. n2Approximately 1.1 billion people in the world lack adequate water and about 2.6 billion are without adequate sanitation. n3 In ad dition, only 1% of the worlds fresh water is usable. n4 The most apparent needs for water can be seen in India, China and Africa, but these examples are not isolated. India and Chinas skyrocketing economic growth have diverted old priorities and added new demands for significant amounts of additional water. n5 Other countries in South America, parts of Asia, Europe, and North America also reflect increasing demands for water. Population growth contributes to the rising demand for water, and the impact of world wide droughts caused by the changing environment has made parts of China and areas of Africa, Australia and the United States extremely vulnerable. Examples of dependence on dwindling water supplies are easily found. Declining levels of water in reservoirs, fresh water lakes and rivers are compounded by declining rainfall. n6 Similar situations can also be found in the western and southeast areas of the United States.Changing population trends, such as movements from the North east and Midwest United States to Atlanta, Phoenix, Las Vegas and parts of California and Texas, contribute to the water shortage problem. Rising energy demands because of urban/suburban growth, legal decisions and *595 continually increasing agricultural demands have also raised awareness and understanding of the importance of maintaining adequate water supplies, preserving high quality water reserves and managing the limited water supply as effectively as possible. n7 In addition, there has been an increased awareness of the interdependence communities and countries have toward one another regarding the preservation and use of fresh water the development and protection of existing water basins and groundwater supplies and the conservation practices and best practices relating to water management.Conflicts over water supplies are not new. In the United States, early conflicts arose over competing agricultural and mining uses later, residents in the Southwest fought in state and fed eral courts as well as at the administrative agency level over the distribution of water from the Colorado River. Currently, Las Vegas is in several disputes regarding its need for water. The situation in Las Vegas invokes the problem demonstrated during the early 1900s, when Los Angeles acquired the water rights in the Owens Valley which left a wasteland of a former agricultural region. n8 Most recently, Lake Mead and Lake Lanier are two examples of the many pending conflicts that focus on competing water demands. n9Current international examples of disputes over water usage and supplies can be found in conflicts arising in and around the Jordan, Saskatchewan and Rhone Rivers. n10 Other areas where concerns have arisen regarding the preservation of significant water supplies include the area surrounding the Guarani Aquifer, which covers an area greater than Great Britain, France and Spain, and provides a water source for more than twenty million people. n11 Another example is the g eneral recognition of the ongoing problem of the Rio Grande or Rio Bravo that is a lifeline for millions of people in the southwestern United States and northern Mexico. The regions aquifers are being depleted from overuse, the new demands created by *596 changes in the demographics, the rapid expansion of Maquiladoras and the increased demands for greater agricultural production. n12Disputes over water among competing interests can be explained by its unique ability to provide a foundation for life and society. The finite nature of water can also explain water disputes at both the local and international level. Additional conflicts may, however, arise and become even more problematic as water becomes a commodity that is controlled by international corporations that can buy, sell and trade this product for their own advantage. Currently, about ten corporations control a large portion of the worlds water supply. They represent a $ 400 billion business and will eventually contribute s ignificant national wealth for some countries and cause other water scarce countries to be dependent on, and even debtor nations to, those companies controlling the worlds fresh water. n13 Some experts have suggested that water and the demand for fresh water will be what oil was during the last century and the lack of fresh water may generate such an intense concern and political discontent that future wars might be fought over trans-border disputes involving water. n14 Many governments and companies have begun seeking ownership or control of existing and potential sources of fresh water. Some governments are planning and building dams and reservoirs to store needed water supplies even if such action might be detrimental to those down river from the projects, and other efforts have been undertaken to control ground water within a countrys boundaries. Recently, the Governor of New Mexico, a presidential candidate, suggested there was a need for a national water policy that would dive rt fresh water from existing sources to those states that had an inadequate water supply. The proposal was not well received by the leaders and people from states having adequate water reserves, and it died a quick and quiet demise. Several other overtures have occurred from both government and business interests seeking water resources from the upper Midwest and Canada one proposal even suggested taking water from the Great Lakes by the tankful. n15A. Water Policy Programs, Problems and ReportsRecognition of the potential problems resulting from competing demands has created several responses. One response has been the Darwinian approach of self- survival or survival of the fittest (those who have the water control those who dont have water). A second approach attempts *597 to create and manage water policies that coordinate competing demands such as residential, agricultural and commercial needs. Attempts are also made to balance rural, urban environmental and political demands. T his second approach requires the use of various experts, community representation, research and a high degree of transparency regarding public decision making.The development of public policy requires the involvement of those with competing interests and values regarding water usage, accurate and dependable data from which options can be evaluated and decisions made, and finally community support based on increased awareness and individual buy-in of the policy choices or recommendations. The likelihood of policy failure or noncompliance with policy directives usually results from lack of accountability or involvement of the appropriate government agency or body, too little funding, failure to balance all interests, unclear rules or guidelines and inappropriate or ineffective dispute resolution mechanisms. n16Specific problems that arise concerning development of water policy are data gaps, or incomplete information the difficulty of reflecting real direct and indirect costs in prici ng improper management of water resources caused by failing to include all jurisdictions affected by the appropriate watershed failure to enforce existing regulations or lack of enforceable rules incomplete intergovernmental oversight of associated issues and shortsightedness in policy related decision-making which fails to balance competing interests. n17 Often these problems cause real conflicts because unanticipated changes in needs, disagreements regarding the costs and values inherent in the policy priorities, and dissatisfaction with the benefits received by some participants compared to the benefits obtained by other competitive interests. Problems may also arise because political influence and pressures that alter the political landscape make compromise difficult or impossible. In some cases water policy problems may be alleviated by new funding sources, different rule interpretations, or recent judicial decisions. Other influences that remove or reduce related conflicts mig ht be the introduction of new technology, changing market conditions, improved conservation practices or improved collaboration among the competing interest groups. n18In order to respond to the real or potential problem, a well thought-out water policy should be followed. Successful implementation of water policy programs require, according to the International Joint Commission 1) accountability based on predetermined obligations, 2) meeting performance standards, 3) accomplishing results based on the means and the agreed upon expectation. n19 The end result of increased accountability should be greater *598 compliance with policy guidelines, greater collaboration, and cooperation between governmental bodies, NGOs and private interests. In order to insure successful compliance with water policy programs it is also essential that a monitoring system be established to investigate and evaluate the activities of the program and its ultimate success or value. A program of evaluation wou ld include a system of measurements or indicators that establish conditions and goals to be accomplished. n20 In addition, a reporting process should be created that would address economic, political, social and technical issues in a credible timely and transparent manner. n21 A comprehensive monitoring system is not in itself sufficient, therefore it is necessary to develop an assessment process that periodically examines the submitted reports and seriously evaluates the policy plan and implementation and makes recommendations to modify, correct or amend the current program to satisfy needs, such as economic, social and political changes. A report should then be made available to the public and those impacted by the water policy. n22The report should set out the policy objectives, goals and resources available in the implementation of the policy. It should also consider options and alternatives to the existing policy and an explanation as to why recommended actions were taken. This report should also consider the financial and environmental impact of the various actions. There might also be a report as to the number and types of conflict that have arisen in regard to the policy. Finally, the report and related documentation should be made available to the public.B. Policy ConflictsThe issue of who will control the water supply raises a variety of questions that often create conflicts. Who can use the water supply, to whom does the water supply belong to and what rights attach to a particular body of water or the owner of that water? Other questions that arise regarding control of water may include can water be a commodity and therefore be sold to the highest bidder without concern for personal needs what is the impact on future generations, or what is the value of water to the general public? Can water be protected under the Public Trust Doctrine because it is, or can be argued that it is like air, a basic necessity of life? n23If one uses the Commons argumen t, then almost any water supply that is managed by a governmental body for the benefit of the public could be included in the doctrine however, if water is not treated as part of the *599 Commons the survival of individuals in society may be threatened. The Commons argument relies on past judicial decisions interpreting property rights and property law. n24Other conflicts may also arise in regard to the water supply. Environmental concerns, economic benefits, the equitable distribution of resources, public participation and partisan decision-making are only a few examples. As we examine the existing water policy dispute mechanisms, it will be important to remember that, because of the wide variety of problems, there may not be a single approach or method capable of resolving all water-related conflicts. Since water supplies have a regional or even greater impact, we should look to dispute mechanisms that encourage wide public participation, allow for public consensus among participa nts and which serve to educate and inform the public about water demand, water conservation techniques and current alternatives to water policy. Special attention should be given the dispute techniques used in international water conflicts between the United States and Canada, and the United States and Mexico.C. Water Policy Dispute MechanismsDisputes over water have been reported since the beginning of recorded history. A war over a water-related issue occurred over 4,500 years ago, and during the last 1,200 years there have been about 3,600 water related international treaties. n25 Since 1870 there have been 145 treaties to manage water, of which 124 are bilateral and twenty-one are multilateral. n26 The principal focus of these agreements has been related to hydropower, but there are other agreements that concern themselves with water distribution for consumption, industrial usage, navigation, pollution and flood control. n27Many of the treaties provide for exchange of data betwe en the signatories of the treaty. This effort provides an opportunity for program administrators and technical experts to build relationships and interdependence within their working group. Some conditions of these water resource treaties include a formula or methodology for allocating water within the agreement or by the use of a board or governing body the use of economic benefits for one or more of the treaty participants recognition that the water resource is unique and must be given special consideration in determining the use and distribution of the water in question and usually downstream participants are given clearer and more specific protection. n28 Treaty participants often negotiate a variety of non-water linkages in their *600 agreements relating to political concessions, exchange of high quality useable water and access to capital and pollution control mechanisms. n29 Many of the international agreements, about 55%, provide for some form of monitoring process, and appr oximately 50% of the treaties provide for some form of dispute resolution process which could include an advisory council, a third neutral party or a designated organization such as the United Nations. n30 In most cases, the dispute resolution mechanisms are rather basic and include some form of consultation, facilitation, mediation and, in some limited cases, adjudication or arbitration. Historically, most water treaties established a hierarchy of uses when negotiating water agreements. Generally, navigation is given priority over other preferences, but today most agreements do not list the order of preferences. Instead, they indicate the options or alternative uses for the water. Usually the preference list would include domestic and municipal uses, industrial uses, navigation, recreational uses, agricultural uses, and energy uses. n31II. INTERNATIONAL APPROACHES TO ENVIRONMENTAL DISPUTESA. Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA)When disputes arise over issues addressed in water-rela ted treaties, the mechanism used in resolving the conflict is often an advisory board, an ad hoc or permanent commission, or a governmental body. These bodies have various levels of authority and frequently must have approval from a national or regional government before a decision can be implemented. Until recently there had been no unified forum to which states, NGOs, individual citizens and corporate or international groups could turn for resolution of their disputes. n32 The Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) may now, however, be used to resolve water disputes.When taken together, the PCA and the Optional Rules for Environmental Conflicts provide interested parties the opportunity to reach an agreement that is acceptable and capable of harmonizing the needs of diverse interests, cultures and values. n33 In addition, the PCA approach provides decision makers who are experienced in environmental matters, who understand the impact of these decisions on the environment and who nee d to maintain a high degree of confidentiality regarding national security *601 issues and proprietary data with a process to produce decisions in a timely manner. n34 The PCA Options are tailored especially for environmental disputes and provide some useful features such as detailed rules for arbitration and conciliation, the use of environmental experts as witnesses, and a process that aids in the facilitation of disputes and the monitoring of any settlement agreement. n35 Currently, over ninety countries have adopted the PCA Environmental Arbitration and Conciliation Rules and have contributed to improving the possibility of environmental disputes being settled more quickly and with greater participant satisfaction. n36The PCA Environmental Rules fill a gap in the decision-making process for environmental disputes that had not been previously filled. The Rules reflect a broad international acceptance of at least two alternatives with defined rules which parties can use and be con fident that they will be heard and given a fair hearing regarding their concerns. The Rules do not solve all the problems regarding environmental conflicts but they are a vast improvement over prior dispute mechanisms. The Rules now bring environmental dispute procedures more closely in line with dispute mechanisms found in, for example, investment treaties or the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL). n37Conflicts regarding the distribution of existing water supplies between treaty participants and/or regarding the order of allocation of water among competing users eventually become a public dispute. Governmental bodies are part of every public dispute and because of their involvement, these disputes take on different characteristics than private conflicts. Generally speaking, the public nature of a dispute means public participation, greater transparency, and possible political pressure. Public disputes are, however, similar to private disputes in that th e dispute resolution mechanisms available to parties in conflict are the basic alternative dispute resolution options or derivatives of these options.B. Dispute Mechanism TechniquesThe two most common dispute resolution techniques are arbitration and mediation.Arbitration or non-binding arbitration occurs when two disputants refer their conflict to a third party decision-maker known as the arbitrator, who will render a decision which will generally be final, or only advisory in *602 non-binding arbitration. Usually arbitrations are the result of a prior contractual agreement, but arbitrations can also begin when the disputants agree to use the arbitration process to resolve a pending dispute. In arbitration or non-binding arbitration the parties select one or more arbitrators, who hear the case as presented by the representatives of the parties and then issue an award or advisory opinion. Most arbitration decisions cannot be appealed. Parties to an arbitration usually need to agree in advance to the arbitration format and the form of the arbitrators report. Arbitration provides parties with an opportunity to select an excellent ethical fact-finder, who will generate an impartial opinion. It avoids problems associated with litigation and creates a binding decision to be followed by the parties. Non-binding arbitration may be valuable because it could provide a speedy decision based on the recommendation of an expert. Parties may not want to use this type of arbitration if cost or timing is a problem. The arbitration process can often reduce conflicts between the parties and reduce the amount of discovery needed.Mediation is a facilitative process. Mediation is a rapidly growing technique that involves a neutral third party trained to assist the parties negotiating an agreement. The mediator has no independent authority and does not render a decision any decision must be reached by the parties themselves. Another definition of mediation refers to mediation being an art and not a science, therefore, the process reflects many different and rich options for dispute settlement. n38 One set of authors say mediation is a process in which an impartial third party acts as a catalyst to help others constructively address and perhaps resolve, plan a transaction or define the contours of a relationship. n39 Finally, Kimberlee Kovach says mediation is the intervention into a dispute or negotiation by an acceptable, impartial and neutral third party who has no authoritative decision- making power to assist disputing parties in voluntarily reaching their own mutually acceptable settlement of issues in dispute. n40The mediation process is simple. The initial stage begins with a preliminary review of the facts by the mediator. Mediation begins with an opening statement that describes the process and sets mutually agreeable ground rules. The second stage begins the fact-finding and is the time for the parties to present their case and to confront the issue s. This is also the time when venting may occur between the parties. During this stage positions are presented, the interests of the parties are discovered and basic agreement on possible solutions might be aired. The next stage includes a discussion of proposed settlement options, and the mediator must generate movement toward settlement if the parties are at an impasse. The final stage is *603 agreement between the parties and negotiating the terms of the settlement agreement.Mediation can be described as facilitative, evaluative or transformative. The facilitative method encourages a problem solving approach to dispute resolution. This method requires the mediator to encourage mutual discussion, exchange of information and creative ideas as to how the dispute might be solved. The facilitative method is designed to build consensus. It is quite flexible in the implementation of the process, and it is the least adversarial between the parties. The evaluative method is focused on the resolution of the dispute. The mediator hears the arguments and then attempts to encourage a particular solution between the parties by using his or her skills, knowledge and expertise. This form of mediation may develop into a shuttle diplomacy approach where the mediator moves back and forth between two rooms and the parties and their lawyers consider various proposals and counter proposals. The third method is a newer mediation approach known as transformative mediation. This method attempts to create a setting that will give the parties the opportunity to exercise their choice and to leave the final decision and responsibility of resolving their conflict to themselves. Healing, reconciliation and the making of a lasting agreement are left to the parties and their individual abilities. The mediator in this approach performs the function of a guide or advisor during the process.Mediation is useful and likely to be successful if the parties have had an ongoing relationship. If cos t is an issue, then mediation is the least costly alternative. If one of the parties finds it necessary to express their emotions or if they get out of control during formal proceedings, then mediation is a workable solution. Mediation, because it is private and flexible, allows for the use of creative solutions and it may allow the parties to communicate more effectively with each other.Mediation can also be referred to as non-directive and directive mediation. Non- directive mediation describes how the mediators operate in regard to their attempts to influence the parties. In this model the mediator avoids making judgments, recommending options and questioning statements and arguments. A directive mediation oriented mediator would express opinions, make proposals, challenge values, question positions and attempt to steer the parties to his or her solution.Prior to most arbitration or mediation efforts there is a period of discussion, consultation or negotiation that frequently res ults in a dispute being resolved, troubling actions modified or sticking points settled. Often these methods are ad hoc, informal and unstructured. The process that precedes formal or structured procedures is known as negotiation.Negotiation, unlike arbitration or mediation, does not require the services of a third party neutral. Usually, the interested parties begin a conversation with one another when they believe there is a misunderstanding. Here they are seeking a benefit or improved situation *604 when compared to their current position or where they try to avoid further escalation of the initial conflict. Negotiation is a conflict resolution technique that settles disagreement and seeks to avoid or prevent future disputes.Consultation may precede a structured negotiation and is frequently used in major contract disputes. Because of the dramatic growth of international trade and the development of the World Trade Organizations (WTO) four-part Dispute Settlement System, its use has increased greatly. Usually consultation is entered into voluntarily and is used to help the parties understand their dispute, how the parties see the issues, and to clarify the legal rights and claims of all parties. WTO records indicate that more than half of their cases are settled or abandoned during the consultation phase. n41 Consultation allows parties to modify their positions, change their understanding or to acquire new information that may influence their action or thinking. n42 Consultation is often voluntary but it may become obligatory if included as a contact clause or treaty requirement. Both negotiation and consultation are devices to encourage cooperation and their use, when mandated, functions as an anticipatory action to avoid or prevent the use of formal or structured dispute settlement mechanisms that are more costly and time consuming.Another possibility when international treaties or conventions are involved and parties to a dispute are not able to reconci le their differences though negotiations is the use of the Good Offices of the governing body of the agreement. Generally, Good Offices means the office of the secretariat of the organization or body responsible for the implementation of the agreement. The use of Good Offices may be as simple as facilitating a conversation between the disputing parties or providing facilities for such a meeting. It may also include the provision of mediation or conciliation services or it may require the actual intervention by an international body. n43 The use of Good Offices has been a frequently used tool in international diplomacy and was integrated in the Hague Convention for the Pacific Settlement of International Disputes in 1907. More recently, similar language has been included in agreements creating the World Trade Organization and the Law of the Sea Convention.Disagreements at the international level often address issues and facts that the parties do not agree to or that they find nearly irreconcilable. When such an impasse occurs it is possible to seek the help of a board of inquiry or a fact-finding body commission to investigate and report findings *605 related to the disagreement. The commission option was initially an ad hoc undertaking that was formalized in the 1899 Hague Convention for the Pacific Settlement of Disputes. n44 The early commissions were established to examine issues in dispute such as when the U.S. battleship Maine was sunk, when the Russian Fleet fired on British fishing vessels in 1904, and when an American woman was killed in a Chilean sponsored car bombing in the United States. n45 These commissions and board inquiries are less frequently used now because other ADR techniques are available and parties are comfortable using them.Conciliation is another ADR method used to resolve international disputes. This method is similar to both mediation and arbitration. Conciliation as a process has been used for about eighty-five years, and over 200 bilateral treaties and many multilateral agreements have language enabling disputants to use this alternative. n46 The idea of conciliation commissions, a combination of inquiry commissions and conciliation, were actually used as early as 1914 but the concept has not become a routine procedure in dispute resolution practice. n47 Conciliation requires a third party neutral to encourage the disputing parties to begin a dialogue with one another and to arrive at a mutually agreeable resolution process. It also requires the neutral to examine the circumstances surrounding the conflict and, after an independent inquiry, make a recommendation based upon the evidence and information that has been discovered during the process of fact finding. n48 The parties are not required to accept the recommendation. Conciliation resembles mediation in its facilitative, non- adversarial and non-binding aspects but it follows formalities more like arbitration, such as investigation, evaluation and decis ion-making. n49 Conciliation has been successful in the few cases where it has been tried, and it provides benefits to the parties because they can reject any recommendation if they desire. n50 In addition,
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)